Policy documents · Coverage changes
Home insurance renewal comparison
Last updated
Is a lower renewal premium buying the same protection? Use this home insurance renewal comparison to check your current policy against the renewal offer. Check changed limits, deductible bases, roof settlement and unresolved wording before treating a price difference as savings.
Bring: both declarations pages, matching policy dates, renewal notices and endorsements. Enter one offer at a time with guided entry. A missing term stays unknown; the worksheet never assumes it is covered.
Compare a home insurance renewal
Home insurance renewal comparison
Put your current policy beside the renewal offer. Start with the premium and dwelling limit, then check roof settlement, rebuilding extensions and a deductible. Optional sections compare other coverage limits and additional deductible events. The checker separates price changes from changed or unconfirmed terms.
Bring both declarations pages, renewal notices and endorsements. Enter only the figures and categories shown there; this tool does not read documents or decide which policy you should buy.
Entries changed. Select Check my renewal differences to refresh the comparison before printing. CSV downloads recalculate the current entries.
Fictional example: renewal differences
Only the entered terms are compared. A matching number does not establish equal coverage, adequate limits or a payable claim.
What to check next
Other terms changed. You identified changed terms, endorsements or exclusions. The price figures do not value those differences. Review these scope entries.
Annualized premium: $100 lower. Annualized fees: No dollar change. Premiums and fees remain separate. This does not compare the value of the protection.
- Roof settlement changes from replacement cost to actual cash value. Check that entry against the roof endorsement and ask the insurer how depreciation or exclusions change.
- The base plus entered rebuilding extension is $52,500 lower. Check the extension wording. This conditional sum is not a promised claim payment.
- The selected deductible is $4,200 higher. Check its event, application and dollar basis before deciding whether you could meet that expense.
Use the questions for your insurer to resolve changed or missing wording. Keep the comparison with both original documents.
On a small screen, scroll the comparison table horizontally to see both policies and the change.
| Item | Current policy | Renewal offer | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium, annualized | $1,800 | $1,700 | $100 lower |
| Fees, annualized separately | $0 | $0 | No dollar change |
| Base dwelling limit (Coverage A) | $360,000 | $390,000 | $30,000 higher |
| Base plus entered extension, if conditions apply | $540,000 | $487,500 | $52,500 lower |
| Dwelling settlement | Replacement cost | Replacement cost | Same selected category |
| Roof settlement | Replacement cost | Actual cash value | Wording differs |
| Selected deductible event | Wind and hail | Wind and hail | Same selected category |
| Deductible application | Each claim / occurrence | Each claim / occurrence | Same selected category |
| Selected deductible, converted to dollars | $3,600 | $7,800 | $4,200 higher |
Premiums and fees are separate; they do not include other policies or financing costs.
Additional coverage and event checks
These rows remain separate. They do not add up to a claim payment or a total amount of protection. Matching limits still require matching terms.
Personal property, loss of use, personal liability, water backup and ordinance/law have not been checked in the optional rows.
A calendar-year deductible is the full stated amount before prior-claim credits. The checker does not decide which deductible applies, whether multiple provisions overlap, or what remains after earlier claims.
Changes to review
- Annualized premium is $100 lower. This is a price comparison, not a finding that the policies protect you equally.
- The base dwelling limit is $30,000 higher. That alone does not show whether rebuilding coverage improved.
- The base plus entered extension is $52,500 lower if its conditions apply. This arithmetic is not a promised claim payment.
- Roof settlement changes from replacement cost to actual cash value.
- For wind and hail with each claim / occurrence application, the entered deductible is $4,200 higher. This is not the amount of a claim payment.
- You identified other changed terms, endorsements or exclusions. They are not quantified in this comparison.
Still needs confirmation
- Any rebuilding extension remains subject to policy conditions. This checker does not determine eligibility, building-code coverage or a claim settlement.
Questions to take to your insurer
- What dated rebuilding estimate supports the new Coverage A limit, and are the home's size, roof age and construction details correct?
- Did the rebuilding extension change, and what conditions, caps, deadlines and exclusions must be met for it to apply?
- How does the changed roof settlement wording affect depreciation, repair conditions or exclusions? Please point me to the applicable endorsement.
- Which event definition activates this deductible, what amount is its percentage based on, and is there a minimum, maximum or prior-claim credit?
- Please list the added or removed endorsements, exclusions and other coverage limits, with the practical effect of each change.
Your comparison record
Fictional example. Invented policy figures; not insurance prices or a coverage recommendation. Method renewal-2026-11-07.2; government guidance checked . These are the entries used for the displayed result. Recalculate after making changes before printing.
| Input | Current policy | Renewal offer |
|---|---|---|
| Full-term premium | 1800 USD per policy termentered | 1700 USD per policy termentered |
| Policy term | 12 monthsentered | 12 monthsentered |
| Base dwelling limit (Coverage A) | 360000 USDentered | 390000 USDentered |
| Dwelling settlement | Replacement costentered | Replacement costentered |
| Roof settlement | Replacement costentered | Actual cash valueentered |
| Additional rebuilding extension | Additional percentage of Coverage Aentered | Additional percentage of Coverage Aentered |
| Additional extension value | 50 percent of Coverage Aentered | 25 percent of Coverage Aentered |
| Selected deductible event | Wind and hailentered | Wind and hailentered |
| Deductible application | Each claim / occurrenceentered | Each claim / occurrenceentered |
| Deductible type | Percentageentered | Percentageentered |
| Entered deductible value | 1 percent of selected basisentered | 2 percent of selected basisentered |
| Percentage basis | Coverage A dwelling limitentered | Coverage A dwelling limitentered |
| Other stated percentage basis | Not entered USDnot used | Not entered USDnot used |
| Separately listed fees | 0 USD per policy termentered | 0 USD per policy termentered |
| State check location | Not selectedunknown | |
| State check policy scope | Not confirmedunknown | |
| Same property, use and insured people | Same home, use and insured peopleentered | |
| Other terms, endorsements and exclusions | Other terms or coverages changedentered | |
“Unknown” means an active entry is missing. An entered 0 remains zero. “Not used” means the field does not apply to the chosen status, type or basis. Blank optional entries omitted here remain unknown: additional coverage status, limits, settlement, application, time limits, document references and additional event deductibles. The CSV lists each of these fields individually.
Methods and limits carried with this record
- Additional coverage limits. Compare only stated limits with the same known application. An excluded coverage is not an unknown amount or a zero-dollar claim. Limits are not added together. Personal-property settlement and loss-of-use time limits are compared separately. Equal numbers do not establish equivalent protection.
- Ordinance or law. A stated dollar limit or a percentage of the explicitly selected basis. A percentage of Coverage A changes when Coverage A changes. No rebuilding extension is added to that basis. Different types or other/unconfirmed percentage bases are not treated as comparable limits.
- Multiple deductibles. Each event is compared separately; deductibles are never summed or selected for an actual loss. Numeric changes require matching known events and application periods, plus matching fixed-dollar types or two percentages of Coverage A. Other bases, different types and unknown triggers require document review.
- Document references. Optional short page or endorsement labels are user-supplied pointers, not verified citations. Do not enter names, addresses, policy numbers or claim details. No policy document is read by this checker.
- Annualization. Full-term premium or fees multiplied by 12 and divided by 6 or 12 policy months. Premiums and fees stay separate. Doubling a six-month figure does not forecast a future renewal price; one-time fees may not repeat.
- Rebuilding extension. Coverage A plus additional dollars, or Coverage A plus its entered extension percentage. No extension explicitly adds zero; unconfirmed and guaranteed replacement wording do not produce a numeric cap. Conditions, building-code coverage and actual settlement are not determined.
- Deductible. A fixed amount or the stated percentage of the selected dollar basis, rounded to cents, half up. A dollar difference requires matching known event and application categories, plus two fixed amounts or two percentages of Coverage A. Floors, caps, definitions and exclusions still require checking.
- Calendar-year amount. The full stated deductible is shown before any prior-claim credit. Remaining annual deductible, event eligibility and claim payment are not calculated.
- Missing information. Blank entries remain unknown. An explicit zero is a supplied value. Inactive fields are retained as not used, never silently applied. Invalid active entries prevent CSV download.
- Scope. Entered rows do not establish equal coverage, adequate protection or which policy to buy. No rebuilding estimate, market premium, loss probability or claim payment is produced. Keep the original declarations, notices and endorsements.
Government guidance
- Texas Department of Insurance: homeowners comparison worksheethttps://www.tdi.texas.gov/consumer/documents/howorksheet.pdf
- Texas Department of Insurance: home insurance guidehttps://www.tdi.texas.gov/pubs/consumer/cb025.html
- Texas Department of Insurance: home renewal reviewhttps://tdi.texas.gov/tips/is-your-home-policy-up-for-renewal.html
- Texas Department of Insurance: deductibleshttps://www.tdi.texas.gov/tips/deductibles.html
- California Department of Insurance: residential insurance guidehttps://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/105-type/95-guides/03-res/res-ins-guide.cfm
Publisher: Insurance Calculator · insurancecalculatorplus.com. Arithmetic and examples are our own; the linked agencies do not endorse or validate this tool. Read the public validation records.
After checking your renewal differences, use your browser's Print or Save as PDF option. The comparison, entered values, open questions and source record are included. Keep your original policy documents; this worksheet is not a replacement for them.
How to compare home insurance renewal offers, with worked examples
Compare your current policy and renewal offer
If you only have the two premium notices, enter those full-term amounts and policy lengths first. The result's “What to check next” section separates the premium change from unconfirmed fees and coverage terms. Its links return you to the relevant step without clearing the other entries. Use the original declarations and endorsements to fill in the rest; an absent figure is not a zero.
A cheaper premium can come with a larger deductible
In the fictional example, the annual premium falls from $1,800 to $1,700. The wind/hail deductible changes from 1% of a $360,000 dwelling limit ($3,600) to 2% of a $390,000 limit ($7,800). The premium is $100 lower while that stated deductible is $4,200 higher. This does not predict a claim, measure the value of the insurance or show which offer is better.
The example also changes the roof settlement from replacement cost to actual cash value. Texas insurance officials recommend looking for this kind of change in renewal documents, along with altered endorsements and exclusions. Texas Department of Insurance: reviewing a home renewal.
Why a higher dwelling limit may tell only part of the story
The example's old limit is $360,000, with a separate 50% rebuilding extension: $360,000 + $180,000 = $540,000. The new limit is $390,000, with a 25% extension: $390,000 + $97,500 = $487,500. The base rises by $30,000 while the conditional sum falls by $52,500. These sums apply only if the extension's conditions are met; they are not guaranteed settlements. A guaranteed replacement provision is shown as wording to verify, without inventing a dollar cap.
California's residential guide distinguishes actual cash value, replacement cost, and provisions that add an amount above a policy limit. It also explains that building-code coverage can require separate attention. Use these categories to ask better questions, then check your own state's guidance and policy wording. California Department of Insurance: residential insurance guide.
The arithmetic and its limits
- Annualized premium: full-term premium × 12 ÷ policy months. Fees use the same formula in a separate row. Six-month figures are doubled for comparison only; a later renewal can have a different price.
- Conditional rebuilding amount: Coverage A plus the entered additional dollars, or Coverage A × (1 + additional percentage ÷ 100). An unconfirmed extension stays unknown; “no extension” explicitly adds zero.
- Percentage deductible: the entered percentage × its stated dollar basis ÷ 100, rounded to cents. Fixed deductibles keep the entered amount. This follows the percentage conversion explained by the Texas Department of Insurance.
- Deductible comparisons: the dollar difference requires matching known event and application categories, plus two fixed amounts or two percentages of Coverage A. Different types and other percentage bases remain separate conversions. Even a matching category needs policy definitions, floors, caps, credits and exclusions checked. No claim payment or remaining annual deductible is calculated.
Read the other coverage lines before comparing the price
Personal property can have different settlement wording from the building or roof. The optional rows also separate loss of use, personal liability, sewer/drain backup and ordinance/law. These choices follow the distinctions in the Texas insurance regulator's policy comparison worksheet and home insurance guide. A selected label records what you found; it does not verify the contract.
| What you find | What the checker shows | What still needs review |
|---|---|---|
| Belongings: $200,000 replacement cost becomes $150,000 actual cash value, both per claim | $50,000 lower limit; a separate settlement change | Depreciation, replacement conditions and special item limits |
| Loss of use: $50,000 per six-month policy becomes $60,000 per twelve-month policy | Both limits; dollar difference withheld | Different policy-term aggregates are not annualized; dollar and time caps remain separate |
| Ordinance/law: 25% of $360,000 becomes 10% of $390,000, both per claim | $90,000 versus $39,000; $51,000 lower | The provision's named basis and conditions; these amounts are not added to a rebuilding extension |
| Backup coverage was excluded; the renewal lists a $10,000 limit | A coverage-status change, with no invented $0 old limit | The covered cause of loss, endorsement and separate deductible; backup is not flood coverage |
When loss of use has both a dollar cap and a month limit, enter both. An unknown time limit stays unknown rather than becoming zero. “No stated dollar cap” does not mean all costs or any duration will be paid. The insurer must explain qualifying expenses and any extensions.
Keep each deductible event and its reference separate
Add up to two more event pairs without replacing the first. For example, a fixed $500 sewer-backup deductible changing to $1,000 per claim produces a $500 increase in that row. It does not increase the separate wind/hail deductible by $500. Different events, application periods or unconfirmed percentage bases prevent a numeric comparison. A calendar-year amount is shown before any prior-claim credit.
Short references such as “declarations p. 2” or an endorsement title/page travel with the CSV and print record. They are pointers you supply, not citations the tool has verified. Leave names, addresses, policy numbers and claim details out of these fields.
Blank or invalid values are not converted into zero. The tool compares the rows you enter, not the entire contract. It does not estimate rebuilding costs, current market premiums, loss probabilities or whether a policy provides sufficient protection. Read a fuller home renewal comparison example.
Keep a complete record of what you compared
Download the full comparison as a CSV after entering your documents. It includes every entered field and its unit, separate labels for unknown and unused values, calculated differences, questions for your insurer, the method version and dated government source links. The download recalculates the entries currently in the form; it stops and identifies invalid entries instead of exporting an older result. Blank fields are allowed and remain unknown.
For a PDF or paper copy, first select “Check my renewal differences,” then use your browser's print option. The result includes the entered values and source record. A comparison started from the fictional example keeps that label even after edits. Select “Start with my documents” to clear the example before entering your own figures. See reproducible validation examples and their limits.
Method and linked government guidance checked . Calculations and examples are our own; the agencies do not endorse this tool.
Renewal case: same premium, higher deductible
Hypothetical figures using an official comparison worksheet. The Texas Department of Insurance’s one-page homeowners comparison worksheet has separate rows for annual premium, deductible, roof settlement and sewer/drain backup. It is blank: the figures below are our constructed exercise, not a Texas rate example, an actual renewal packet or evidence of customer savings.
Scroll the table sideways to compare the current policy and renewal.
| Where to look | Current policy | Renewal |
|---|---|---|
| Declarations: full-term premium | $2,600 | $2,600 |
| Declarations: Coverage A | $300,000 | $330,000 |
| Deductible schedule: wind/hail, per claim | 2% of Coverage A | 2% of Coverage A |
| Roof endorsement: settlement wording | Replacement cost | Actual cash value |
| Sewer/drain backup endorsement: per-claim limit | $10,000 | $5,000 |
The premium change is $0. The wind/hail deductible still says 2%, but 2% × $300,000 is $6,000 and 2% × $330,000 is $6,600: $600 more per applicable claim before considering other policy terms. A fixed 2% input does not mean a fixed dollar obligation. The Maryland Insurance Administration’s declarations guide explains the distinction between a percentage of Coverage A and a percentage of a claim.
The backup limit is $5,000 lower. The roof’s settlement wording also changes, but the checker does not turn depreciation into an invented dollar loss. The roof’s age, condition, valuation rules and endorsement determine what that change means. Texas officials specifically flag roof valuation and endorsement changes in their renewal review guidance.
What to copy, and what to leave unknown
Copy the two annual premiums and twelve-month terms first. Next enter each Coverage A amount, the wind/hail event, per-claim application, 2% rate and Coverage A basis. Record roof settlement in its own row. For backup coverage, confirm both endorsements use the same per-claim application before comparing their dollar limits. The worksheet’s backup row asks whether that cause of loss is covered; a limit alone does not explain all its conditions.
If the renewal packet lacks the backup endorsement, leave the renewed status or limit unconfirmed. Do not enter $0 or assume exclusion. The useful next question is: “Can you send the renewal’s roof and backup endorsements, and explain the dollar wind deductible using the new dwelling limit?” These changes are separate findings; adding $600 and $5,000 would not estimate a claim or the value of the policy.
Case version 1.0; source worksheet and linked guidance checked . Policy fees, rebuilding extensions and all other coverage terms are unconfirmed in this exercise. Download the constructed inputs, source mapping and expected results (JSON).
Compare your own renewal documents · Read the evidence scope and limitations
A renewal price difference is only the first check
First compare premiums over equivalent policy periods. Then work through the changes the price alone cannot describe. The worksheet keeps dollar differences, wording changes and unknown entries distinct so that an incomplete offer cannot appear to provide matching coverage.
Separate the dwelling limit from additional rebuilding terms
A higher base dwelling limit can accompany a smaller percentage extension. Enter the base amount and extension separately, then check the conditions in the endorsement. A rebuilding estimate is also different from the home’s sale price. Use the home insurance calculator when your task is comparing a dated rebuilding estimate with one policy’s limit.
Check the deductible’s amount, basis and event
A percentage is incomplete without the dollar amount it applies to. Two offers with the same percentage can have different dollar deductibles if their dwelling limits differ. A separate hurricane or wind/hail deductible also needs its own trigger and wording. The optional Florida and Texas checks provide specific questions within their stated scope; they do not infer how an unreported claim will be settled.
Read roof and belongings settlement terms
Keep replacement cost, actual cash value and any payment schedule distinct. A lower premium paired with a changed settlement basis needs explanation even if the general coverage limit rises. Record whether the relevant endorsement was supplied. Do not translate missing wording into a zero-dollar limit or an automatic match.
Turn the results into questions for the insurer
Export the entered figures, document references, mismatches and unknowns. Ask for the exact page or endorsement that resolves each uncertainty. Recalculate after the insurer supplies it, and save a new browser draft only when you want to replace the previous draft. This produces a comparison record; it does not decide whether an individual claim is payable.
The Texas Department of Insurance home insurance guide explains coverage and settlement distinctions. Its homeowners comparison worksheet provides a document checklist. Policy terms and state rules vary; the in-tool state panel gives the checked source and the applicable scope.
Continue with the worked renewal-notice guide or load a case from the public validation records. Fictional examples and government sample documents are labeled separately from real customer outcomes.