Written loan offers · US purchase mortgages
FHA vs conventional loan calculator
Last updated
Which written offer fits the years you expect to keep the loan? Use this FHA vs conventional loan calculator to compare an FHA loan with a conventional loan, or two FHA offers. Start with one document, then add the other.
Bring: both Loan Estimates, the purchase price, expected holding period and written mortgage-insurance terms. Optional Closing Disclosure lines help reconcile closing cash. Leave missing figures blank; examples are not current quotes.
Compare two written offers
Compare two FHA loans or FHA vs conventional
Compare monthly payments, closing cash and financing costs using two written offers.
Inputs changed. Compare the offers again to update the result.
Your FHA vs conventional comparison
Started from a fictional example. Results may include your edits. Confirm every input against your offers. The original figures demonstrate the method, not market prices or available offers. Use Clear comparison to start with blank amounts.
Before using this comparison
Start with these checks. Then compare monthly budget, upfront cash and financing cost separately.
- The optional Loan Estimate check has not been used. Scenario entries have not been compared with quoted document amounts. Check the quoted figures.
Use the lender’s Estimated Cash to Close for closing cash; the subtotal below excludes adjustments. Save the comparison and open questions.
Inputs and method saved with this comparison
Scroll the input table sideways to see the values and their units.
| Input | Value | Unit or basis |
|---|---|---|
| Comparison type | FHA versus conventional | choice |
| FHA loan-term suitability | confirmed | choice |
| Conventional loan-term suitability | confirmed | choice |
| Purchase price | 400000 | USD |
| FHA adjusted value | 400000 | USD |
| Selected holding period | 5 | years |
| FHA down payment | 3.5 | percent |
| FHA fixed note rate | 6 | percent |
| FHA loan term | 30 | years |
| FHA upfront MIP payment | finance | choice |
| FHA net cash loan costs | 3500 | USD |
| Conventional down payment | 5 | percent |
| Conventional fixed note rate | 6.25 | percent |
| Conventional loan term | 30 | years |
| Conventional monthly PMI | 150 | USD/month |
| Conventional PMI duration basis | manual | choice |
| Conventional original purchase appraisal | Unknown / not entered | USD |
| Ordinary borrower-paid PMI applicability assumption | Unknown / not entered | choice |
| Conventional stated PMI duration | 120 | months |
| Conventional upfront insurance | 0 | USD |
| Conventional net cash loan costs | 3000 | USD |
| Property taxes | 4800 | USD/year |
| Homeowners insurance | 1800 | USD/year |
| HOA or condo dues | 0 | USD/month |
| FHA case-assignment year | 2026 | year |
| State | AL | state |
| County selector | AL001 | county selector |
| FHA Loan Estimate issue date | Unknown / not entered | date |
| FHA rate-lock note | Unknown / not entered | text |
| FHA quoted Loan Amount | Unknown / not entered | USD |
| FHA quoted initial principal and interest | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| FHA quoted initial mortgage insurance | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| FHA quoted initial Estimated Escrow | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| FHA quoted initial Estimated Total Monthly Payment | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| FHA quoted Cash to Close | Unknown / not entered | USD |
| Conventional Loan Estimate issue date | Unknown / not entered | date |
| Conventional rate-lock note | Unknown / not entered | text |
| Conventional quoted Loan Amount | Unknown / not entered | USD |
| Conventional quoted initial principal and interest | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| Conventional quoted initial mortgage insurance | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| Conventional quoted initial Estimated Escrow | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| Conventional quoted initial Estimated Total Monthly Payment | Unknown / not entered | USD/month |
| Conventional quoted Cash to Close | Unknown / not entered | USD |
Method: loan-comparison-2026-11-09.1. Sources checked . Fixed rates; scheduled monthly payments; final rounding adjustment; FHA MIP follows each loan’s annual schedule; conventional PMI, when selected, follows the stated or conditional duration. Costs are undiscounted. There is no appreciation, tax, investment-return or refinancing assumption. No eligibility or loan recommendation is made.
Rules and comparison guidance: HUD MIP rules, HUD county limits, CFPB Loan Estimate comparison, CFPB PMI removal. See public validation records.
FHA county limit: $541,287. 2026 one-unit limit for AUTAUGA COUNTY, AL.
- FHA base loan: $386,000 — within the selected county limit.
This is a loan-size check, not credit approval. A known county-limit failure withholds lower-cost callouts.
Initial loan payment
Conventional: $40.96 less per month
Entered-scenario comparison of principal, interest and mortgage insurance only. Add taxes, homeowners insurance and HOA dues for the housing budget. Upfront costs are separate.
Financing cost over 5 years
Conventional: $7,467.47 less
Interest, upfront and periodic insurance, and entered loan fees. Principal and down payment are separate below.
On a narrow screen, scroll the table sideways to compare both offers.
| Measure | FHA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment / purchase contribution | $14,000 | $20,000 |
| Starting loan balance | $392,755 | $380,000 |
| Monthly principal and interest | $2,354.76 | $2,339.73 |
| Initial monthly mortgage insurance | $175.93 | $150 |
| Initial loan payment: principal + interest + insurance | $2,530.69 | $2,489.73 |
| Monthly taxes + home insurance + HOA | $550 | $550 |
| Initial housing budget, including those three items | $3,080.69 | $3,039.73 |
| Upfront mortgage insurance incurred once | $6,755 | $0 |
| Upfront mortgage insurance paid in cash | $0 | $0 |
| Other net loan costs paid in cash | $3,500 | $3,000 |
| Selected upfront cash subtotal (not Cash to Close) | $17,500 | $23,000 |
| Interest through year 5 | $114,006.57 | $115,065.02 |
| Periodic insurance through year 5 | $10,270.92 | $9,000 |
| Financing cost through year 5 | $134,532.49 | $127,065.02 |
| Principal repaid over that period | $27,279.03 | $25,318.78 |
| Remaining loan balance after that period | $365,475.97 | $354,681.22 |
Premium assumptions: FHA uses a 0.55% annual MIP rate, recalculated on the scheduled balance each year, for 30 years. The entered fixed terms are 30 years for FHA and 30 years for conventional. Conventional PMI is held at the quoted monthly amount for 120 months using the stated/manual basis. This is a modeled duration, not a promise of cancellation. No premium is charged after the modeled loan term ends.
The upfront cash subtotal adds the down payment, cash-paid upfront mortgage insurance and net loan fees. It excludes deposits, seller credits, prepaid interest, escrow reserves and other closing adjustments. Your Loan Estimate’s Cash to Close is an estimate; confirm the final settlement amount on your current Closing Disclosure with the lender. Principal repaid is a change in debt, not a forecast of home equity. Property value, selling costs and investment returns are not modeled.
What changes if you keep the loan longer?
Compare the same two offers at each holding period. Financing cost includes interest, mortgage insurance and the entered net loan costs. Down payments and repaid principal stay separate. Rates, loan terms and quoted conventional PMI stay fixed; this is a time comparison, not a forecast of future offers.
The cost order does not change at any modeled monthly checkpoint, from closing through the longer loan’s maturity. This does not make either loan a recommendation.
Year-by-year financing costs
Scroll the table sideways to compare both costs and the difference.
| Holding period | FHA cost | Conventional cost | Cost difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| At closing | $10,255 | $3,000 | Conventional lower by $7,255 |
| Year 1 | $35,800.27 | $28,423.88 | Conventional lower by $7,376.39 |
| Year 2 | $61,021.29 | $53,561.36 | Conventional lower by $7,459.93 |
| Year 3 | $85,898.05 | $78,393.99 | Conventional lower by $7,504.06 |
| Year 4 | $110,409.29 | $102,902.17 | Conventional lower by $7,507.12 |
| Year 5 · selected | $134,532.49 | $127,065.02 | Conventional lower by $7,467.47 |
| Year 6 | $158,243.67 | $150,860.35 | Conventional lower by $7,383.32 |
| Year 7 | $181,517.49 | $174,264.49 | Conventional lower by $7,253 |
| Year 8 | $204,326.93 | $197,252.31 | Conventional lower by $7,074.62 |
| Year 9 | $226,643.28 | $219,797.05 | Conventional lower by $6,846.23 |
| Year 10 | $248,436.27 | $241,870.16 | Conventional lower by $6,566.11 |
| Year 11 | $269,673.52 | $261,641.33 | Conventional lower by $8,032.19 |
| Year 12 | $290,320.86 | $280,878.26 | Conventional lower by $9,442.60 |
| Year 13 | $310,341.86 | $299,546.60 | Conventional lower by $10,795.26 |
| Year 14 | $329,697.85 | $317,609.77 | Conventional lower by $12,088.08 |
| Year 15 | $348,347.73 | $335,028.87 | Conventional lower by $13,318.86 |
| Year 16 | $366,248.08 | $351,762.42 | Conventional lower by $14,485.66 |
| Year 17 | $383,352.64 | $367,766.38 | Conventional lower by $15,586.26 |
| Year 18 | $399,612.31 | $382,993.79 | Conventional lower by $16,618.52 |
| Year 19 | $414,974.95 | $397,394.69 | Conventional lower by $17,580.26 |
| Year 20 | $429,385.39 | $410,915.94 | Conventional lower by $18,469.45 |
| Year 21 | $442,784.70 | $423,500.97 | Conventional lower by $19,283.73 |
| Year 22 | $455,110.61 | $435,089.55 | Conventional lower by $20,021.06 |
| Year 23 | $466,296.89 | $445,617.56 | Conventional lower by $20,679.33 |
| Year 24 | $476,273.30 | $455,016.81 | Conventional lower by $21,256.49 |
| Year 25 | $484,965.15 | $463,214.69 | Conventional lower by $21,750.46 |
| Year 26 | $492,293.28 | $470,133.92 | Conventional lower by $22,159.36 |
| Year 27 | $498,173.55 | $475,692.26 | Conventional lower by $22,481.29 |
| Year 28 | $502,516.63 | $479,802.15 | Conventional lower by $22,714.48 |
| Year 29 | $505,227.73 | $482,370.47 | Conventional lower by $22,857.26 |
| Year 30 | $506,206.23 | $483,298.06 | Conventional lower by $22,908.17 |
After either loan matures, its modeled financing cost stops accumulating. Shared property taxes, homeowners insurance and HOA costs are excluded from this table; they continue while you own the property. No home appreciation, investment return, refinance, tax effect, selling cost or discount rate is assumed. The CSV includes every monthly checkpoint, interest, insurance, principal repaid and remaining balances.
How to compare Loan Estimates for FHA and conventional loans
Start with your own figures: choose Clear comparison before entering your two offers. A fictional example is useful for learning, but partial edits can leave sample costs in the result. After calculating, use the “Before using this comparison” checklist to find missing figures or Loan Estimate differences. Correct those entries before treating the cost order as a comparison of your offers.
Compare written Loan Estimates for the same purchase and, where possible, issued on the same day. The interest rate, loan term, amount borrowed and mortgage-insurance arrangement can all differ. A smaller down payment can preserve cash while leaving a larger balance and a higher financing cost. There is no single best loan based on the monthly payment alone. The CFPB’s Loan Estimate comparison guide separates monthly payments, upfront costs and the five-year cost of borrowing.
Comparing two FHA loan offers
Choose Two FHA offers and apply the comparison type. Enter each offer’s own down payment, note rate, 15- or 30-year term, upfront MIP payment choice and net cash loan costs. The same purchase price, lender-confirmed adjusted value, county, case-number year and household bills apply to both. If the lenders use different adjusted values or case-number years, ask them to explain and align those assumptions before using this comparison.
For example, on the same $400,000 purchase, a 6% FHA offer with $5,000 of net loan fees and a 6.125% FHA offer with $2,500 of net loan fees trade a lower rate against lower upfront costs. Enter the actual down payment and upfront-premium choice for each. The monthly payment alone cannot settle that trade-off: use the holding-period table to compare cumulative financing costs and keep the cash needed at closing separate.
Both FHA offers use HUD’s annual MIP calculation, rather than a fixed monthly insurance quote. Each loan’s original loan-to-value and term determine its MIP rate and duration. Financing upfront MIP adds its financed whole-dollar amount to the loan; any remaining cents are cash due. The premium is counted once as a financing cost in either payment method. The county check tests each base loan separately, and either known limit failure withholds the cost-order conclusion. The optional document check and complete CSV include both offers.
1. FHA vs conventional: compare cash, cost and principal separately
The selected cash subtotal adds the purchase contribution, upfront mortgage insurance paid in cash and the other net cash loan costs you enter. It is not the lender’s Cash to Close. Financing cost adds interest over your holding period, periodic mortgage insurance, the full upfront mortgage-insurance charge and net loan fees. Principal repayments reduce the balance; they are not added to that cost.
If FHA upfront MIP is financed, the entire premium is counted once as a financing charge. The payment and interest calculation include the financed amount. Its principal repayment is not counted as an additional charge. The remaining debt includes any financed premium still unpaid. This is why financing cost and cash spent by a particular date are different measures.
2. Choose a PMI duration basis you can explain
Use a lender’s stated charge count when available. Otherwise, deliberately choose a scheduled assumption and enter the conventional purchase appraisal. Original value is the lower of that appraisal and the sale price; FHA adjusted value is not reused. A missing appraisal leaves the derived duration unknown. Selecting manual duration overrides the scheduled assumption.
The automatic scenario stops charges before the earlier scheduled 78% termination payment or first payment after the term midpoint. The request scenario assumes approval after the scheduled 80% payment, capped at the automatic duration. These are billing conventions for comparison, not promised removal dates. Current payments and other applicable conditions still matter. Actual charges and refunds can differ; verify the disclosure with the servicer. CFPB PMI cancellation guidance.
Arithmetic example, not an offer: a $90,000 loan on a $100,000 original value at a hypothetical 0% fixed rate for 30 years repays $250 a month. It reaches 80% after payment 40 and 78% after payment 48. This worksheet’s conventions model 40 PMI charges for the approved-request scenario or 47 for the automatic scenario. At a hypothetical $100 per charge, that is $4,000 versus $4,700. A lender-provided billing schedule takes precedence over either assumption.
3. Compare the complete initial housing budget
The housing-budget row adds principal, interest, initial mortgage insurance, one-twelfth of annual property tax and homeowners insurance, plus monthly HOA or condo dues. Those amounts are entered once whether paid through escrow or directly. All three optional property-cost fields must be known for this row to be calculated.
This initial budget is not a forecast: property taxes, insurance and dues can change. Maintenance, utilities, special assessments and other required property coverage can add expenses. The CFPB explains the difference between principal and interest and the total payment.
4. Check the FHA loan size before relying on the comparison
The FHA base loan is tested against the selected county and case-assignment year before financed upfront MIP. A loan above that local limit is prominently flagged and receives no lower-cost callout. If no county is selected, the result says the local limit was not checked. The comparison does not determine income, credit, property or conventional program eligibility.
FHA MIP follows HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05: a 1.75% upfront premium and annual MIP bands determined by the base loan, adjusted value and term. The modeled MIP duration is 11 years at an initial LTV of 90% or less and the loan term above 90%. Special programs and refinances are outside this purchase model. Annual scheduled balances and cent rounding follow HUD’s premium calculation method; the rate bands above use the current premium rules, rather than the older rates in HUD’s worked example. County limits come from HUD’s mortgage-limit lookup.
5. Test the time you expect to keep the loan
The holding-period table keeps both offers fixed and shows cumulative financing costs at closing and after each year. A loan with higher upfront costs can have lower interest or insurance later; the opposite can also happen. The monthly check looks for every change in cost order, including equality and a later reversal. It does not interpolate an exact break-even date or promise that you will keep the loan that long.
At each checkpoint, financing cost counts the entire upfront insurance charge once, entered net loan costs, accrued interest and periodic insurance. A remaining financed premium is still part of outstanding debt. Down payments and repaid principal are shown separately in the comparison and export. When a loan reaches maturity its financing costs stop, although the household still has property expenses. The analysis does not assume a refinance, rising property value, an investment return on retained cash or future interest rates.
Use the complete CSV when discussing the offers with a lender: it records your inputs, what remains unknown, the method version, county-limit check, selected results and every monthly checkpoint. Missing fees or PMI assumptions prevent a cost-order conclusion; an FHA loan above the selected county limit receives none either. The public validation records explain the checked arithmetic cases and what those checks do not establish.
6. Check your Loan Estimate figures before comparing costs
The optional document check pairs page 1 Loan Terms with the modeled opening balance and principal-and-interest payment. Copy the first Projected Payments column for mortgage insurance, escrow and total payment. It records each issue date and rate-lock note so an older quote is not mistaken for an equivalent current offer.
Loan amount and principal-and-interest checks allow one cent; initial insurance and total payment allow $1 for displayed rounding. An amount within that allowance is not certification. A discrepancy can come from financed charges, a different term, a revised rate or a different payment period. Conventional PMI is checked against your entered quote, not priced independently.
Estimated Escrow is copied from the offer, not verified against tax bills. The document payment adds that escrow to modeled principal, interest and mortgage insurance; the separate housing budget also includes bills paid directly. The optional Cash to Close check adds the signed lines copied from a standard purchase Loan Estimate page 2 or Closing Disclosure page 3 Final column. It includes the document’s total closing costs, financed costs, funds from or for the borrower, deposit, seller credits and adjustments; the Closing Disclosure also subtracts costs paid before closing. Blank applicable lines withhold the sum. This checks the table arithmetic, not the correctness or eligibility of the underlying charges. Total Closing Costs (J) already includes its lender credits, prepaids, escrow funding and listed insurance: never add them a second time. Upfront MIP or PMI can appear in section B; do not include it again in other loan costs. Use the CFPB’s annotated Loan Estimate to locate each field.
7. Reconcile closing cash without counting costs twice
Copy one document and column per offer, including minus signs. A deposit reduces the cash still due; it is not a discount on the house. A positive adjustment adds to cash due and a negative adjustment subtracts from it. A negative final sum means funds to the borrower. Do not substitute the down-payment percentage or the modeled loan-fee subtotal for the disclosure’s own rows.
For the CFPB’s historical sample Loan Estimate, $8,054 of total closing costs + $18,000 of funds from the borrower − $10,000 deposit, with the remaining rows at $0, equals $16,054. This is a form-arithmetic example, not current pricing. If a Closing Disclosure lists costs paid before closing, copy that separate negative row too; do not subtract the deposit again. The calculation follows the standard tables in Regulation Z §1026.37(h)(1) and §1026.38(i). Alternative tables, refinances and simultaneous subordinate financing are outside this check.
Calculation boundaries. Payments use a fixed rate and monthly amortization with cent rounding; the last payment settles any rounding remainder. There are no extra payments, missed payments, rate changes or refinances. Confirm both offers have fixed rates and principal-and-interest payments, fully amortizing terms, no prepayment penalty and no balloon. Unknown or unsupported terms withhold lower-cost and crossover conclusions; fixed-rate arithmetic alone cannot establish the cost of another product. The comparison ends at the earlier of the selected holding period and each loan’s term. FHA annual MIP is recalculated from the scheduled balance; conventional PMI uses your quoted amount and either a stated duration or explicitly selected conditional schedule. Other loan costs and conventional upfront PMI are paid in cash. These are undiscounted modeled amounts, not an APR calculation, tax analysis or official Loan Estimate.
Sources checked: . Use the CFPB Loan Estimate explainer to find the actual loan terms, lender credits and Cash to Close. Change the input figures when the lender revises an offer.
Two document-backed mortgage comparison cases
1. Closing costs rise while cash to close falls
Actual federal sample documents, not a current offer or a customer result. The CFPB publishes a paired fixed-rate Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure. Their loan amount stays at $162,000, with a 30-year term and 3.875% note rate. Following the same loan through both documents reveals why a smaller closing-day payment does not necessarily mean lower closing costs.
Open the CFPB Loan Estimate H-24(B), form page 2 and the matching Closing Disclosure H-25(B), form page 3. Each PDF has a cover sheet before the numbered form pages.
Scroll the table sideways to compare both documents.
| Document line | Loan Estimate | Closing Disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Total Closing Costs (J) | $8,054.00 | $9,712.10 |
| Costs already paid before closing | $0.00 | −$29.80 |
| Down payment / funds from borrower | $18,000.00 | $18,000.00 |
| Deposit already paid | −$10,000.00 | −$10,000.00 |
| Seller credits | $0.00 | −$2,500.00 |
| Adjustments and other credits | $0.00 | −$1,035.04 |
| Cash to Close | $16,054.00 | $14,147.26 |
The final sum is $9,712.10 − $29.80 + $18,000 − $10,000 − $2,500 − $1,035.04 = $14,147.26. Closing costs increased by $1,658.10, while the additional cash required at closing decreased by $1,906.74. The deposit was paid earlier; it did not disappear from the buyer’s spending. Both documents list $0 of closing costs financed and $0 of funds for the borrower.
2. Find the housing expense outside the lender payment
On Closing Disclosure form page 1, the first payment column adds $761.78 principal and interest, $82.35 mortgage insurance and $206.13 escrow to reach $1,050.26 a month. The HOA box says those dues are not escrowed. Form page 4 lists $1,800 a year of non-escrowed HOA dues: $150 a month. The selected initial housing budget is therefore $1,200.26 a month. Adding the full $356.13 Taxes, Insurance & Assessments line to the $1,050.26 payment would count $206.13 twice.
For your own documents, separate the payment made to the servicer, property bills paid directly and cash due at closing. Check the issue date and the first payment period before copying figures. The CFPB Loan Estimate explainer identifies the relevant lines; our optional document check compares the entries you supply.
Scope boundary: these historical samples disclose a prepayment penalty during the first two years. Our purchase comparison does not model prepayment penalties, so this is a document-reading case, not a complete loan-cost simulation or a recommendation to enter this loan as a supported offer. The budget excludes utilities, maintenance and future changes in costs. The agency’s sample rates are not today’s prices.
Source documents: CFPB H-24(B) and H-25(B), published February 7, 2014. Figures and arithmetic checked . Download the source references, inputs and expected results (JSON).
How we check these public document cases · Download the independent arithmetic checker (Python)
Read three different answers from the comparison
Can I afford the recurring payment?
Check principal and interest, mortgage insurance, property taxes, homeowners insurance and any association dues. A smaller escrow estimate does not establish a cheaper lender offer. Confirm which housing costs are outside escrow and compare the same property and period.
How much money must I bring to closing?
Use the document reconciliation separately from the borrowing-cost comparison. Deposits and seller credits affect the closing-day amount. Prepaids and escrow funding are different from lender charges; do not enter a total that already includes a fee again as a separate fee. The worksheet identifies missing lines and mismatches, rather than certifying a lender’s closing statement.
What does borrowing cost over my holding period?
Interest, entered financing costs and mortgage insurance contribute to modeled borrowing cost. Principal repayment reduces the balance and is shown separately. Compare nearby holding periods and changes to quoted rates or fees. A lower modeled cost depends on complete inputs and supported loan features; it is not approval, underwriting or a future refinance offer.
The CFPB’s loan-offer comparison guide distinguishes payments, upfront costs and cash to close. Its five-year document check subtracts principal paid from the total paid shown in the Loan Estimate’s comparison section. This worksheet adds user-selected holding periods and explicit mortgage-insurance assumptions.
Choose the tool that matches the decision
- One conventional loan: use the PMI cost and removal timeline calculator for original-value milestones and extra principal.
- FHA down payment and eligibility context: use the FHA mortgage insurance calculator for the housing budget and supported HUD county/year loan-limit lookup.
- Two written offers: stay here to compare financing costs, closing cash and document assumptions. Select the two-FHA mode when both offers are FHA.
See the public validation records for runnable fictional cases and independent reference arithmetic. Government source documents explain rules and form fields; our examples do not imply agency endorsement or an independent professional review.