{
  "version": "document-cases-2026-11-08.1",
  "checked_on": "2026-11-08",
  "publisher": "Insurance Calculator",
  "evidence_scope": "Two investigations of paired federal sample documents and one constructed renewal exercise using a blank state worksheet. No customer outcomes, current lender offers, independent professional review or agency endorsement are claimed.",
  "sources": [
    {"id": "cfpb-le", "title": "CFPB H-24(B): fixed-rate Loan Estimate sample", "url": "https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201403_cfpb_loan-estimate_fixed-rate-loan-sample-H24B.pdf", "published": "2014-02-07", "document_issue_date": "2013-02-15", "pdf_sha256": "243551dbce6362e616328924eaf5b1818b734883d43ec91a73c160e5da52b385", "pagination": "Form pages 1-3 are PDF pages 2-4; PDF page 1 is a cover sheet."},
    {"id": "cfpb-cd", "title": "CFPB H-25(B): paired fixed-rate Closing Disclosure sample", "url": "https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201403_cfpb_closing-disclosure_cover-H25B.pdf", "published": "2014-02-07", "document_issue_date": "2013-04-15", "pdf_sha256": "606a93c8baaca815439822df5cf8c78cbb2dcf6cc4af5aa291a459c7917e4173", "pagination": "Form pages 1-5 are PDF pages 2-6; PDF page 1 is a cover sheet."},
    {"id": "cfpb-explainer", "title": "CFPB Loan Estimate explainer", "url": "https://www.consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/loan-estimate/", "scope": "Document line locations and distinctions between closing costs, cash to close, escrow and directly paid property costs."},
    {"id": "tdi-worksheet", "title": "Texas homeowners company/policy comparison worksheet", "url": "https://www.tdi.texas.gov/consumer/documents/howorksheet.pdf", "scope": "One-page blank worksheet; separate premium, deductible, dwelling/personal property/roof valuation and sewer/drain backup rows. It supplies categories, not the constructed exercise values."},
    {"id": "tdi-renewal", "title": "Texas Department of Insurance: Is your home policy up for renewal?", "url": "https://tdi.texas.gov/tips/is-your-home-policy-up-for-renewal.html", "scope": "Sections 1, 3 and 5 identify roof valuation, percentage deductible and endorsement changes to review."},
    {"id": "maryland-declarations", "title": "Maryland Insurance Administration: Understanding Your Home Owners Insurance Declarations Page", "url": "https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Pages/Home-Understanding-Declarations.aspx", "scope": "Explanation of percentage deductibles based on Coverage A, rather than on claim size, and reading endorsements for coverage terms."}
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "cfpb-closing-cash",
      "kind": "official-sample-document-reconciliation",
      "title": "Higher closing costs, lower cash to close",
      "source_locations": ["cfpb-le: form page 2, Calculating Cash to Close", "cfpb-cd: form page 3, Calculating Cash to Close; Sections K and L"],
      "input_unit": "USD; credits and previous payments are stored as positive magnitudes and subtracted",
      "inputs": {
        "estimate": {"closing_costs": "8054.00", "paid_before": "0.00", "financed_costs": "0.00", "down_payment": "18000.00", "deposit": "10000.00", "funds_for_borrower": "0.00", "seller_credits": "0.00", "other_credits": "0.00", "document_cash_to_close": "16054.00"},
        "final": {"closing_costs": "9712.10", "paid_before": "29.80", "financed_costs": "0.00", "down_payment": "18000.00", "deposit": "10000.00", "funds_for_borrower": "0.00", "seller_credits": "2500.00", "other_credits": "1035.04", "document_cash_to_close": "14147.26"},
        "final_other_credits_components": {"title_rebate": "750.00", "seller_unpaid_tax_adjustment": "365.04", "buyer_hoa_adjustment_due": "80.00"}
      },
      "expected": {"estimate_cash_to_close": "16054.00", "final_cash_to_close": "14147.26", "closing_costs_change": "1658.10", "cash_to_close_change": "-1906.74", "final_other_credits": "1035.04"},
      "limitations": ["These are historical sample documents, not actual transactions or current prices.", "The original sample has a prepayment penalty in its first two years; the site's purchase comparison does not model such penalties. This case is document arithmetic, not a full loan-cost simulation.", "The deposit is earlier cash paid and is not a reduction in the home's cost."]
    },
    {
      "id": "cfpb-housing-budget",
      "kind": "official-sample-document-reconciliation",
      "title": "The lender payment leaves out directly paid HOA dues",
      "source_locations": ["cfpb-cd: form page 1, first Projected Payments column and Estimated Taxes, Insurance & Assessments", "cfpb-cd: form page 4, Escrow Account, non-escrowed property costs over Year 1"],
      "inputs": {"monthly_principal_interest": "761.78", "monthly_mortgage_insurance": "82.35", "monthly_escrow": "206.13", "document_monthly_payment": "1050.26", "annual_non_escrow_hoa": "1800.00", "monthly_taxes_insurance_assessments": "356.13"},
      "expected": {"lender_payment": "1050.26", "monthly_direct_hoa": "150.00", "selected_housing_budget": "1200.26", "double_counted_budget": "1406.39", "double_counted_amount": "206.13"},
      "limitations": ["Initial amounts only; does not forecast taxes, insurance or HOA changes.", "Utilities, maintenance, repairs, other assessments and costs outside these selected lines are not included.", "The deliberately incorrect double-counted budget is a teaching counterexample, never a recommended result."]
    },
    {
      "id": "tdi-renewal-exercise",
      "kind": "constructed-exercise-using-government-worksheet",
      "title": "Same premium and deductible percentage, different dollar exposure",
      "source_locations": ["tdi-worksheet: page 1, Annual premium, Deductible, Replacement cost or actual cash value / Roof, and Backup of sewers, drains", "tdi-renewal: sections 1, 3, 5", "maryland-declarations: percentage deductible and endorsement explanations"],
      "provenance": "All policy amounts and renewal changes below are invented for this exercise. No filled official renewal sample or real customer packet is claimed.",
      "inputs": {
        "current": {"term_premium": "2600.00", "term_months": "12", "dwelling": "300000.00", "deductible_percent": "2", "deductible_basis": "Coverage A", "event": "wind and hail", "application": "per claim", "roof": "replacement cost", "backup_limit": "10000.00", "backup_application": "per claim"},
        "renewal": {"term_premium": "2600.00", "term_months": "12", "dwelling": "330000.00", "deductible_percent": "2", "deductible_basis": "Coverage A", "event": "wind and hail", "application": "per claim", "roof": "actual cash value", "backup_limit": "5000.00", "backup_application": "per claim"}
      },
      "expected": {"current_annual_premium": "2600.00", "renewal_annual_premium": "2600.00", "annual_premium_change": "0.00", "current_deductible": "6000.00", "renewal_deductible": "6600.00", "deductible_change": "600.00", "backup_limit_change": "-5000.00"},
      "form_inputs": {"renewal_action": "compare", "renewal_example": "1", "renewal_property": "same", "renewal_terms": "changed", "renewal_old_premium": "2600", "renewal_new_premium": "2600", "renewal_old_months": "12", "renewal_new_months": "12", "renewal_old_dwelling": "300000", "renewal_new_dwelling": "330000", "renewal_old_event": "wind_hail", "renewal_new_event": "wind_hail", "renewal_old_period": "claim", "renewal_new_period": "claim", "renewal_old_deductible_type": "percent", "renewal_new_deductible_type": "percent", "renewal_old_deductible_value": "2", "renewal_new_deductible_value": "2", "renewal_old_basis": "dwelling", "renewal_new_basis": "dwelling", "renewal_old_roof": "rc", "renewal_new_roof": "acv", "renewal_old_water_backup_status": "included", "renewal_new_water_backup_status": "included", "renewal_old_water_backup_limit": "10000", "renewal_new_water_backup_limit": "5000", "renewal_old_water_backup_application": "claim", "renewal_new_water_backup_application": "claim"},
      "limitations": ["Policy fees, other coverage terms and rebuilding extensions remain unconfirmed.", "Roof settlement is a wording change only; depreciation is not priced.", "Deductible and coverage-limit changes are separate results, not summed into a claim or policy value.", "If the renewed backup endorsement is missing, renewed status/limit remain unknown and a numeric limit difference is withheld."]
    }
  ]
}
